Leakage
Leakage is an increase in emissions outside a carbon project's boundary that the project itself causes, reducing its real climate benefit.

What is Leakage?
Leakage happens when a carbon project causes emissions to rise somewhere else. The project seems to cut emissions, but part of the activity has simply moved. The IPCC describes leakage as "the effects of policies that result in a displacement of the environmental impact," which counteracts their intended effect (IPCC, 2022).
The classic example is forest protection. If logging stops in a protected forest but demand for timber stays the same, loggers may cut trees in another forest. The net benefit for the climate is then smaller than the credits suggest. Leakage is one of the core quality tests for any carbon credit, next to additionality and permanence.
Types of leakage
Activity-shifting leakage occurs when the same people move their activity, such as farming or logging, to a nearby area. Market leakage occurs when lower supply raises prices, which encourages others to produce more elsewhere. Activity shifting is usually local and easier to track, while market leakage can spread across regions or countries.
Removal projects can cause leakage too. A 2025 study of reforestation in Brazil estimated leakage of about 12% of the reforested area through displaced cattle ranching (Silva and Nunes, 2025).
How standards deal with leakage
Crediting methodologies estimate leakage and deduct it from the credits a project can issue. Verra's improved forest management rules, for example, apply deductions of 0, 20, 40 or 70%, depending on where harvesting is likely to move (Haya et al., 2023). Jurisdiction-wide approaches reduce leakage by measuring a whole region instead of one project. Under the EU CRCF, removals must outweigh "any direct or indirect GHG emissions" linked to the activity (European Commission, 2024).
Why is Leakage important?
Leakage can quietly erase a project's climate benefit. If the deduction is too small, buyers pay for tonnes that were never really reduced or removed.
Research suggests deductions are often too low. A 2023 review of forest carbon protocols cited leakage estimates of 16 to 68% for US forest set-aside programs. It concluded that "leakage rates are generally higher than those commonly used in the protocols" (Haya et al., 2023).
Leakage risk differs by method. It is highest for projects that change land use or restrict production, such as forest protection. Engineered removals such as direct air capture have little activity-shifting risk, but their energy use and supply chains must still be counted in a lifecycle assessment.
Under SBTi V2.0, supported mitigation outcomes must "meet recognized third-party high-integrity criteria, where applicable, and SBTi minimum integrity criteria" (SBTi, 2026). The SBTi Removal Budget Planner helps plan the credit mix.
How Cawa looks at Leakage
Every project in a Cawa portfolio is analyzed with Cawa's own quality framework, built over years of analyzing 400+ projects with students from TU Delft, Utrecht University and VU Amsterdam. The framework includes repeated monitoring over time to catch early red flags.
Sources
- IPCC AR6 WGIII, Annex I Glossary (2022)
- Silva and Nunes, Leakage Effects from Reforestation, Land (2025)
- Haya et al., Comprehensive review of carbon quantification by improved forest management offset protocols, Frontiers in Forests and Global Change (2023)
- European Commission, Q&A on the CRCF Regulation (2024)
- SBTi Corporate Net-Zero Standard V2.0, Chapter 6 (2026)
Written by Joris Herbermann, Carbon Removal Specialist at Cawa. Last updated 16 November 2026.
Related terms
Want to explore this topic further? Browse connected glossary terms below.
Frequently asked questions
Projects that restrict an economic activity without reducing demand for it. Forest protection and improved forest management are the most exposed, because demand for timber or farmland can shift to other areas. Reforestation on farmland can displace crops or cattle. Engineered removals such as direct air capture and BECCS have low activity-shifting risk, though their supply chains still need full accounting.
Methodologies estimate how much activity moves outside the project and deduct that share from the credits. Some use fixed deduction rates, others model local markets or compare with control areas. Verra's improved forest management rules apply deductions of 0 to 70% depending on the case (Haya et al., 2023). Jurisdiction-wide accounting reduces leakage by covering a whole region.
Yes. Any project can shift emissions elsewhere. A reforestation project can push cattle ranching into nearby land; one study in Brazil estimated leakage of about 12% of the reforested area (Silva and Nunes, 2025). For engineered removals, the bigger question is indirect emissions from energy and materials, which a lifecycle assessment must include.