Lifecycle Assessment (LCA)
Lifecycle assessment (LCA) is a standardized method (ISO 14040/14044) to measure environmental impacts across a product's whole life, from raw materials to disposal.

What is Lifecycle Assessment (LCA)?
A lifecycle assessment (LCA) measures the environmental impacts of a product, service or process across its whole life: raw materials, production, transport, use and end of life. In carbon removal, it shows whether a project removes more CO₂ than it emits. LCA is also the basis for product carbon footprints.
Two international standards govern LCA. ISO 14040 sets out the principles and framework, and ISO 14044 the requirements and guidelines. Both date from 2006, were "last reviewed and confirmed in 2022" and remain current (ISO, 2022; ISO, 2022).
The four phases of an LCA
ISO 14040 describes four phases (ISO, 2022):
- Goal and scope definition sets what is studied, for whom, and where the system boundary lies.
- Inventory analysis collects data on energy, materials, emissions and removals.
- Impact assessment translates that inventory into impacts such as climate change.
- Interpretation draws conclusions and tests how sensitive they are.
ISO 14040 also covers reporting and critical review, so independent experts can check a study. The system boundary shapes the result. Cradle-to-gate stops at the factory gate, while cradle-to-grave also includes use and end of life. LCA results are only comparable when goal, scope and boundary match.
LCA in carbon removal
Every removal method causes some emissions. For biochar, that includes growing or collecting biomass and running the pyrolysis plant. For enhanced weathering, it includes mining, grinding, transporting and spreading rock. A credit should only reflect the net removal, never the gross amount captured. The EU CRCF does this by subtracting "the increase in direct and indirect greenhouse gas emissions over the entire lifecycle of the activity" from the removal (EU Regulation 2024/3012, 2024).
Why is Lifecycle Assessment (LCA) important?
LCA separates a real net removal from a gross capture number. A critical review of carbon removal LCAs found that results "can be easily misinterpreted as negative emissions". It concluded that for most methods the available results were "not representative nor reliable" (Terlouw et al., 2021). The review covered 36 studies on biochar, 11 on BECCS and only 3 on DACCS.
The same applies to CO₂ use. The IEA notes that "CO2 used is not the same as CO2 avoided", and that quantifying climate benefits requires a full lifecycle assessment (IEA, 2019).
For buyers, this means looking past headline tonnes. Ask which system boundary was used, whether upstream and end-of-life emissions are included, and how the result is checked through MRV. A removal budget planned with the free SBTi Removal Budget Planner is only as strong as the net tonnes behind it.
How Cawa looks at Lifecycle Assessment (LCA)
Every project in Cawa's portfolios is analyzed with Cawa's own quality framework, built over years of analyzing 400+ projects with students from TU Delft, Utrecht University and VU Amsterdam. The framework includes repeated monitoring over time to catch early red flags.
Sources
- ISO 14040:2006, Principles and framework (confirmed 2022)
- ISO 14044:2006, Requirements and guidelines (confirmed 2022)
- Regulation (EU) 2024/3012, CRCF (2024)
- Terlouw et al., Life cycle assessment of carbon dioxide removal technologies: a critical review, Energy & Environmental Science (2021)
- IEA: Putting CO2 to Use (2019)
Written by Joris Herbermann, Carbon Removal Specialist at Cawa. Last updated 16 November 2026.
Related terms
Want to explore this topic further? Browse connected glossary terms below.
Frequently asked questions
Because capturing and storing CO₂ always causes some emissions, from energy, transport, materials and land use. Without an LCA, a project could report gross capture instead of net removal. The EU CRCF subtracts lifecycle emissions from the removal, and a credible credit should reflect only the net tonnes taken out of the atmosphere.
Cradle-to-gate counts impacts from raw material extraction until a product leaves the factory. Cradle-to-grave also includes transport, use and end of life, such as disposal or recycling. For carbon removal the full chain matters, including storage. A critical review of carbon removal LCAs recommends a cradle-to-grave perspective because many studies left out end-of-life impacts.
The core standards are ISO 14040, covering principles and framework, and ISO 14044, covering requirements and guidelines. Both were reconfirmed in 2022 and remain current. Carbon removal methodologies and the EU CRCF add method-specific rules on top, for example on what counts as lifecycle emissions and how removals are quantified.